WASHINGTON — ²Ñ¾±²õ²õ´Ç³Ü°ù¾±â€™s quasi-governmental student loan agency is coming under harsh criticism from some Democrats, as the agency has become pivotal in Republican efforts to block President Joe Biden’s attempts to eliminate student loan debt for millions of Americans.
The criticism follows the filing of a lawsuit by Missouri Attorney General Andrew Bailey challenging a Biden administration plan to relieve student loan debt for some Americans, including at least 2,780 Missourians.
Bailey’s lawsuit cites harm done to the Chesterfield-based Higher Education Loan Authority of the State of Missouri, better known as MOHELA.
At a Senate Banking subcommittee hearing on Wednesday, Democratic senators criticized Bailey and other Republican attorneys general for pushing back against the Biden administration’s attempts to wipe out student loan debt.
People are also reading…
Kansas City Mayor Quinton Lucas, who testified in front of the committee, said the lawsuits are being filed for political purposes and hurting people who are burdened by thousands in debt.
“There’s nobody in Kansas City, nobody in ºüÀêÊÓƵ or anywhere in the state who’s been asking (for this),†said Lucas, a Democrat. “And I think what we’re seeing and what we’ve seen today is how many people nationally are impacted. They are looking to get standing to continue to bring these challenges based on the relationship between MOHELA and the state of Missouri, but really the harm extends far beyond it.â€
Scott Giles, executive director and CEO of Chesterfield MOHELA, declined an invitation to appear before the committee. Instead, MOHELA’s defense was left to Scott Buchanan, the executive director of the Student Loan Servicing Alliance.
Buchanan noted that student loan providers have stayed neutral about the Biden administration’s efforts to eliminate student loan debt.
The senators were focused on two lawsuits. The first, called Biden v. Nebraska, was a suit filed against the Biden administration’s efforts to use powers granted to the executive branch in a state of emergency to wipe out up to $30,000 in debt for millions of Americans.
Missouri joined that lawsuit under former attorney general, and now senator, Eric Schmitt. As it made its way to the Supreme Court, ²Ñ¾±²õ²õ´Ç³Ü°ù¾±â€™s role in the case became essential because it helped give the states the legal grounds to sue over the Biden administration’s plan.
“The Secretary’s plan will cut MOHELA’s revenues, impairing its efforts to aid Missouri college students,†Chief Justice John Roberts wrote in the majority opinion striking down Biden’s plan. “This acknowledged harm to MOHELA in the performance of its public function is necessarily a direct injury to Missouri itself.â€
The Biden administration then launched a second effort to forgive student loan debt, which hinges on a series of changes to the student loan program by the Department of Education.
²Ñ¾±²õ²õ´Ç³Ü°ù¾±â€™s Bailey filed a lawsuit Tuesday challenging one part of that plan, called the SAVE plan, in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Missouri. His lawsuit, which was joined by six other states, followed a similar action by Kansas Attorney General Kris Kobach.
But while MOHELA has played a central role in giving the attorneys general grounds to sue, it hasn’t willingly participated in the suits. In Biden v. Nebraska, Missouri had to file a Sunshine Request to get the documents it needed to make its case.
Sen. Raphael Warnock, a Georgia Democrat, questioned how much the lawsuits help Missourians.
“When I think of all the things that we need attorneys general to be engaged in to protect their constituents, somehow ²Ñ¾±²õ²õ´Ç³Ü°ù¾±â€™s attorney general wakes up in the morning and thinks this is the great service that the people of Missouri and the people of this country need,†Warnock said.
The senators — and most of the panel in front of them — were also critical of how MOHELA handles loans.
When student loan payments resumed following a temporary hiatus during the COVID-19 pandemic, MOHELA was late in sending letters to 2.5 million people, according to Persis Yu, the deputy executive director and managing counsel for the Student Borrower Protection Center.
Of those letters, around 280,000 contained inaccurate information about how much money was owed, according to the Student Borrower Protection Center, a nonprofit that advocates for the elimination of student debt.
MOHELA, which is facing two class action lawsuits, has claimed the findings by the Student Borrower Protection Center are false and filed a cease-and-desist letter.
Buchanan laid the blame for the problems facing borrowers on the feet of the U.S. Department of Education, saying much of the trouble comes from confusing orders and a lack of monetary support.
“The department is constantly changing the rules as they go and they don’t give us enough money to do it,†Buchanan told the Star after the hearing. “Then they tell us to cut call center hours because they can’t afford to pay for it, and then we’re surprised that people sit on hold. This is all knowable, this is all predictable.â€
Sen. Elizabeth Warren, a Massachusetts Democrat and the chair of the Senate Banking Committee’s subcommittee on Economic Policy, was not convinced. She criticized MOHELA for being unprepared as Americans began repaying student loans after the COVID-19 pandemic, calling the agency “shockingly bad.â€
“MOHELA has repeatedly failed millions of borrowers and it’s time for real action and accountability,†Warren said.
Any federal action may take a while. For much of the hearing, Warren was the only senator in the room.
She was later joined by four more Democratic senators — Warnock, Sen. Robert Menendez, a New Jersey Democrat plagued by scandal; Sen. Chris Van Hollen, from Maryland; and Sen. John Fetterman, from Pennsylvania. No Republicans attended the hearing.
The Department of Education has the ability to rescind MOHELA’s contract as a federal student loan provider, but it recently renewed MOHELA’s contract for another five years.